Hard September Decisions

Reading Time: 3 minutes



Baseball becomes a strange sport in the late summer. As the playoff races begin and trade deadlines approach, front offices across the league have to make a series of hard decisions, beginning with the core question: “Can my team make the playoffs?”

There are significant financial benefits if a team makes a deep playoff run, and as many commentators continue to remind us, flags fly forever.

Teams like the Red Sox, Yankees, Giants, Dodgers, or Cardinals can easily afford to take a risk by spending money or trading prospects in a season where they are unlikely to win the World Series, but small-market or historically unsuccessful teams do not have that luxury. Trading prospects or signing expensive free agents can devastate future seasons for some teams.

Organizations such as the Cubs and Astros are particularly interesting. They are historically and currently horrible and they are not just rebuilding, but they are rebuilding with a plan and a timeline. Many expect both of these teams to be playoff or pennant contenders in the next few years as they stockpile top prospects and convince their ownership that the big day is coming soon.

With this in mind, what happens when the front office is wrong? What happens when you think it is your year and you are simply dead wrong? This week, I’d like to remind readers of one such occasion, when the Seattle Mariners sold the farm in an attempt to win.

Leading the AL West by 3.5 games and with memories of the 1995 post-season run in mind, the M’s decided to shore up their rotation and bullpen by offloading prospects and young players. Seattle sent Jason Varitek and Derek Lowe to Boston in exchange for the fairly mediocre reliever/closer Heathcliff Slocumb. At the moment it may have seemed to be pragmatic, but most could tell it was shortsighted.

Also Read:  Today in the MLB: Charlie Blackmon hitting .400 and more great stats...

To make up for our lack of situational knowledge as the 15 years of passing time make us highly susceptible to 20/20 hindsight, we will simply look at advanced metrics. Varitek had no major league experience, but was clearly a top prospect. Both Slocumb and Lowe were below replacement level at -0.8 WAR, but Slocumb had proven experience, coming off of a 3.1 WAR season.

Lowe was unproven, but had potential. Hoping for more stability, and potentially seeing a return to Slocumb’s previous performance, the Mariners made a move intended for the post-season and neglected the future. But, flags fly forever.

On the same day, Seattle traded the young slugger Jose Cruz Jr. to the Blue Jays for additional bullpen help in the form of Mike Timlin and Paul Spoljaric (Timlin was thrown in, with the real prize being Spoljaric). Once again, this was a textbook case of shortsighted trades. Seattle was leading the league in runs per game with 5.71, but was almost half a run below the league average in runs allowed per game.

It is easy to see how these trades were pitched to the front office and ownership, yet looking back nearly everybody can see that they were an utter failure.

The Mariners finished the regular season in good shape, improving their lead to six games over the Angels, but couldn’t hold the heavy hitting Orioles who beat them 9-3 twice in the Kingdome before a series clinching victory in Game 4. The Mariners slipped back into mediocrity for the 1998 and 1999 seasons before reaching the post-season again.


Cody Zoschak
Cody Zoschak is a freelance writer based out of Washington D.C. He writes almost exclusively about baseball and the growing trend towards statistically driven management.
Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Rahul’s Historic Ton Thumps Bangalore

KL Rahul struck the highest score by an Indian in Indian Premier League as Kings XI Punjab beat Virat Kohli-led Royal Challengers Bangalore by 97 runs. Rahul, who scored 132 not out, also achieved the highest individual score by a captain and the best for a Kings XI Punjab player with a generous Royal Challengers Bangalore bearing the brunt of his assault, offering little in the form of resistance. After being invited to bat first, KXIP...

The Torchbearers Of Modern Football

We are standing at the end of an era that was tinted with brightness and glam. Two of the greatest sportsmen ever to grace the surface of earth are at the twilight of their careers. They are aliens, some say. Some say they are superheroes in shorts. Two names at the heart of the footballing world, for the best part of two decades. The torchbearers of modern day football. The pace-setters of the business...

Different Options For Purchasing Golf Shoes

Golf is one of the most popular sports among wealthy and upper middle class men. While some play golf competitively, others play golf as a hobby and for networking with others. The performance of the golfer depends to some extent on the golfing gear and equipment which he is using. Usually golfers are wearing special golf shoes, which are designed so that the golfer can play his shots comfortably, without slipping. Hence many of...

Russell Wilson Is An All-Time Great QB

Russell Wilson, 0 MVPs, 0 MVP votes, 0 respect. He is one of the best quarterbacks I've ever seen, and he is showing himself to be the MVP so far this year. Russell Wilson at every stage of his career has consistently been elite and has carried the Seahawks into relevancy. He is underrated, has been elite, and has been one of the best QBs in the world since he's gotten here. How is it that...

Super Fan Saturday – Rugby South Africa

In what has been an extremely long-awaited return for the game, South Africa will host their very first rugby game: Super Fan Saturday, since the sport was postponed back in March 2020. While this year may have been challenging times for the majority of the world, a doubleheader action-packed Saturday will bring something to look forward to locally. and keep every South African rugby fan at the edge of their seats. One of the nation's...

AFL Finals Locked In

This weekend's results conclude the heavily disrupted Australian Football League regular season, turning attention towards the Finals series in October.
Also Read:  The Most Emotional Night In Baseball History...
Across 18 rounds spanning six weeks, the race for the coveted Premiership trophy has been whittled down from 18 clubs to just eight. All that separates them from the 2020 flag now is four weeks of playoff matches that will culminate in the Grand Final. Port Adelaide secured the minor premiership by defeating Collingwood in the...

Rabada, Stonis star as Super Over settles dramatic IPL game

Kagiso Rabada and Marcus Stoinis starred for the Delhi Capitals as they controlled their nerves to edge Kings XI Punjab in Super Over. Rabada dismissed KL Rahul and Nicholas Pooran while conceding just 2 runs in the deciding over. Rishabh Pant and Shreyas Iyer batted for Delhi in the Super Over and settled the game in 2 balls. Heartbreak for Mayank Agarwal It was a heartbreak for Mayank Agarwal who scored 89 runs in 60 balls, but...

America’s Largest Amateur League Shines in Baseball’s “Lost Season”

2020 will forever be remembered as baseball’s lost season. The sport was shattered due to the COVID-19 pandemic virus outbreak. Baseball fans were out of luck this summer as they were entirely restricted from attending any professional or semi-pro live games. Watching on television or live stream wasn’t much better. Most of the MLB season was cancelled including the pre-season, the much anticipated Iowa Field of Dreams game, Puerto Rico series, London Series and All...

IPL: Mumbai Indians Lose Season Opener

Mumbai Indians lost an Indian Premier League (IPL) opener for the 8th successive year following a 5-wicket loss to Chennai Super Kings. Having lost the first game of the season in the last 7 years, Mumbai might have thought this was their time, as they were on a 5-game winning run against CSK. However, ex Mumbai Indians player Ambati Rayudu and South African superstars Faf du Plessis and Lungi Ngidi ensured that it didn’t...

When Did Formula One Begin?

If you ask virtually anyone the world over a simple question – “What is Formula One” they will probably get the answer correct.  It’s a car race!  Even though that might be a very simple reply (a better answer would be it’s the highest class of international single-seater auto-racing!) there is another question that will probably stump them.  That question is “When did Formula One begin?”. In order to answer the question properly we need...

Social Connect


Trending Now

Super Fan Saturday – Rugby South Africa

In what has been an extremely long-awaited return for the game, South Africa will host their very first rugby game: Super Fan Saturday, since...
Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x