Super Rugby is losing its passion

Reading Time: 3 minutes

The idea to globalise the Super Rugby competition and incorporate more international teams from Japan and Argentina in 2016 was an interesting idea at the start. On one hand the NZ teams could get a look over the world and promote their brand, while on the other hand the level of competition and excitement for New Zealand fans may decline. The second is exactly what has happened, and there is no denying it.

The Hurricanes absolutely demolished both the Sunwolves and Rebels in the first two weeks, with an aggregate score of 159-23; but were put to the sword by the Chiefs in Hamilton on Friday. The Chiefs start the season 3-0 with three intense NZ derbies, and have looked slick on offense. The Blues managed a strong win over the Rebels 56-18 in the opening game of the season, but the Auckland based team is still on the rise, and may not be at full flight until rounds 5-7 after two average displays against the Chiefs (discipline) and Highlanders (errors) the last two weeks. The Crusaders, like the Blues, are yet to be at their best under new coach Scott Robertson; though have impressively started the season 3-0 like the Chiefs. Whether you want to think the level of class in the New Zealand teams is far beyond anyone else or not, the cracks are starting to widen and the opponents are starting to crumble in the other conferences. The Blues still managed an 8-6-1 record last season even though ranking last among the New Zealand teams, with a heavily inexperienced squad, and Umaga’s first year at the helm. There have been consistent complaints by the NZRU about the toughness of the New Zealand conference, and how, arguably in comparison, the finals are a walk in the park for them.

The Rebels, the earliest ‘newby’, entered the competition in 2011, with a lot of support from the Australian rugby group as well as SANZAR. The depth of talent that Australia had to offer compared to New Zealand and South Africa at the time just was not enough for a new side in Melbourne, so this brought into question why a new team was needed. Players from all over Europe and New Zealand were being plucked and dropped into Tullamarine, and the Rebels are, unsurprisingly, yet to make a playoff run in their minimal seven year career. The Kings from South Africa had a brief stint in Super Rugby in 2013 when the Lions were severely under-performing (Oh how times change), but only lasted one year when they were beaten in a two-leg series prior to the 2014 season. Unsurprisingly one again, an under strength Kings side managed 3 wins from 16 games in 2013. The Kings returned last year along with the new Japanese-based side the Sunwolves, but both teams are pure rubbish compared to the likes of the Chiefs and Highlanders, and even the Reds or Bulls for example. Both teams finished with a combined record of 3-1-26, and a points difference of -736. Even worse, none of them managed a win, let alone a close result against New Zealand teams. To put it nicely, none of the previous teams seem to add anything exhilarating to the competition.

Also Read:  Super Rugby Aotearoa Week 10: Highlanders vs Hurricanes

The Jaguares are a bit of an outlier. They managed some wins against the Bulls and Lions a year ago, and close defeats to the Chiefs and Blues. So logically, they should be at least considered for a continuous appearance in the competition. But another argument with the new teams is distance to travel simply to play one game, which takes down the logicality of the Jaguares. A game in Argentina will require a long plane trip, on top of the South African trips the teams must endure, and a game against a team who may be decent on their day, but severely un-reliable. But the South Africa trips often have at least two way games, where for example you might play the Bulls, the Sharks and then on the way home play the Force in Perth. Therefore some sense goes into the fixture planning, which simply cannot work with Argentina.

Is going back to the Super 12/14 format a solution? Yes. It has a feeling of moving backwards instead of forward, but sticking to the roots at this stage is the best bet. Australian teams have seemed to lose their footing recently, and the lack of depth, which hurt the Rebels in their inaugural season, is hurting the rest of the teams now. That would be the main reason for their ‘downfall’, but the teams are part of the Super rugby heritage, they make it up and all deserve a place in the mix still.

14/15 teams, you play each other once a year without conferences, and six to eight teams making the finals. A simple, interesting and what will be invigorating format that is the solution. Is distance to travel and class enough to overall money? It should be. Rugby is too down to earth to care about advertising to such a degree; this is not Soccer. Therefore it should not be an easy decision to say no to expansion and yes to passion.

Lachlan Waugh
19 year old University student, aspiring to become a sports journalist.
Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Tewatia plays blinder as Rajasthan chase historic total to beat KXIP

Rahul Tewatia hit 5 sixes in an over as Rajasthan Royals chased down the highest score in Indian Premier League history to beat Kings XI Punjab by four wickets on Sunday. Tewatia hit Sheldon Cottrell for five sixes in the 18th over and added another six of the next ball he faced as Rajasthan chased down 224. Jofra Archer hit 13 from 3 balls to see the side home. Rajasthan beat their own record – they...

NRL Finals Loom as Regular Season Concludes

The first fixtures of the National Rugby League's finals series are locked in after the final round of the regular season came to an end today. The Competitors While Penrith Panthers had already secured the minor premiership and the top eight were determined two rounds ago, some key positions were still open and the race for those positions made for some entertaining footy. The Newcastle Knights failed to hold sixth place, going down on Friday to a...

Russian GP – Race Preview

Russian Grand Prix can be a boring race so let's hope this race gets off to a great start. The only memory I have of the Russian GP is Valtteri Bottas letting Lewis Hamilton win. Last race at Mugello was an exciting race. With two red flags and one horrible crash. And Ferrari 1000 celebration wasn't the best either, but that might be because of the strict rules now during COVID 19. So I am happy...

Benny Leonard: Always A Champion

If you sat down with a group of boxing fans under the age of say, 50, and began to talk about whether Benny Leonard really is a Top-10 all-time fighter, you'd probably have a cacophony of voices barking at you about how great "Sugar" Ray really was. Tell them you were talking about Benny Leonard though, and you might hear a lot of "Who's that?" from the same group. But Benny Leonard most definitely belongs...

The Green Light: The Rugby Championship 2020

In what has been a challenging year for many rugby fans and mainly the players, the Southern Hemisphere's Rugby Championship 2020 tournament has just been confirmed for the back end of the season. The Rugby Championship tournament - previously known as the Tri-Nations - was inaugurated in 1996 with the three rugby-rich countries; Australia, New Zealand and South Africa, all contesting for the converted trophy. In 2012, the tournament expanded to add the South...

IPL Talking Points

Efficient CSK get the job done again Before the tournament began, the Chennai Super Kings were touted to struggle by everybody analysing the game. But, on the opening day, post the opening powerplay overs, MS Dhoni proved once again why the IPL betting odds are always in their favor. From a position where they could have chased a tall score, CSK restricted MI to a chaseable total and then led by solid innings from...

Rahul’s Historic Ton Thumps Bangalore

KL Rahul struck the highest score by an Indian in Indian Premier League as Kings XI Punjab beat Virat Kohli-led Royal Challengers Bangalore by 97 runs. Rahul, who scored 132 not out, also achieved the highest individual score by a captain and the best for a Kings XI Punjab player with a generous Royal Challengers Bangalore bearing the brunt of his assault, offering little in the form of resistance. After being invited to bat first, KXIP...

The Torchbearers Of Modern Football

We are standing at the end of an era that was tinted with brightness and glam. Two of the greatest sportsmen ever to grace the surface of earth are at the twilight of their careers. They are aliens, some say. Some say they are superheroes in shorts. Two names at the heart of the footballing world, for the best part of two decades. The torchbearers of modern day football. The pace-setters of the business...

Different Options For Purchasing Golf Shoes

Golf is one of the most popular sports among wealthy and upper middle class men. While some play golf competitively, others play golf as a hobby and for networking with others. The performance of the golfer depends to some extent on the golfing gear and equipment which he is using. Usually golfers are wearing special golf shoes, which are designed so that the golfer can play his shots comfortably, without slipping. Hence many of...

Russell Wilson Is An All-Time Great QB

Russell Wilson, 0 MVPs, 0 MVP votes, 0 respect. He is one of the best quarterbacks I've ever seen, and he is showing himself to be the MVP so far this year. Russell Wilson at every stage of his career has consistently been elite and has carried the Seahawks into relevancy. He is underrated, has been elite, and has been one of the best QBs in the world since he's gotten here. How is it that...

Social Connect


Trending Now

NRL Finals Loom as Regular Season Concludes

The first fixtures of the National Rugby League's finals series are locked in after the final round of the regular season came to an...
Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x