Home Cricket Questions regarding England’s Ashes selectors

Questions regarding England’s Ashes selectors

“It is hard to imagine a more stupid or dangerous way of making decisions than by putting those decisions in the hands of people who pay no price for being wrong”. So said Thomas Newell, the economist, words which now seem awfully relevant to the selection panel for England’s 2017/2018 Ashes squad.

Mick Newell, Angus Fraser and James Whitaker (chairman of selectors) were the men tasked with choosing England’s latest cricket team to face Australia. In the two years preceding this most important of tours, their picks have seemed to raise more questions and doubts than answers.

Chairman of selectors James Whittaker with former England batsman Jonathan Trott

Before Mark Stoneman made his Test debut in August, eight other batsmen had made their England debuts since 2015. Only one of those eight averages more than 28 in Tests (Haseeb Hameed, 43.80). Whilst James Vince and Dawid Malan, who both average under 25, will be given a chance to remedy that this winter, the others have been consigned to the ever-growing scrapheap of batters unlikely ever to be seen again in the highest form of the game.

James Vince only averaged 33 in the County Championship this year

The questionable picks are not only limited to the batsmen, however. Toby Roland-Jones has undoubtedly been a success but before that three spinners were welcomed into the fold. Between them, they share only 16 Test matches and their bowling averages are some way short of what is considered “decent” by international standards – Rashid (43), Ansari (55) and Dawson (43).

The quicks have not fared much better, with Chris Jordan (36), Mark Wood (41) and young Jake Ball (114) all so far failing to hold down a regular place in the team.

Going back to Gary Ballance in 2014, it seems remarkable that of the last 22 cricketers to make their debuts in this format for England, only four are likely to start the opening Ashes match next week at the Gabba. Although injuries may have played their part, it could also be said that Vince and Malan are more than fortunate to be getting an opportunity. These figures do not suggest that the selection trio are getting it right.

Dawid Malan fared little better in Division One this year, averaging 35

So are the selectors facing a distinct lack of accountability? Whittaker, Newell and Fraser had all been in their roles at least a full year before Andrew Strauss was appointed director of England cricket in May 2015. These are not men that Strauss has chosen to fulfill the role. It begs the question, much like when Juvenal asked “Who will guard the guards themselves”, Who selects the selectors?

As England prepare to face Australia with perhaps the most unsettled Ashes team they’ve had for many years, who should face the flack if things go pear-shaped down under? The players of course are likely to face some uncomfortable truths in the press and head coach Trevor Bayliss will be scrutinised. But perhaps questions should be asked of the three whose job it is to actually pick the players who must go into battle next week. “Outstanding individuals” they may be, as the director of cricket described them, but also individuals who one week shy of the first Test have left England, as Strauss continued to say, without “absolute clarity on what our best XI is”.

Have the right decisions been made regarding England’s batsmen?


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


Leeds Rock Villa Boat as Bamford Pounces

Bamford's first hat-trick for Leeds ensures victory over Villa

Billy Joe Saunders Defends WBO Title against Martin Murray on December 4.

Eddie Hearn of Matchroom Boxing has today confirmed that WBO Super Middleweight Champion Billy Joe Saunders will make his return to the ring after a one-year layoff. Saunders will defend his WBO Crown against fellow Brit Martin Murray on December 4 on Sky Sports and DAZN. A contest between Saunders and Murray has been scheduled two times prior for Saunders' WBO Middleweight Belt in 2018 but postponed both times due to injuries from Billy Joe. Murray...

Super Rugby Unlocked 2020: Bulls Vs Sharks

Every South African rugby fan will shift their attention to Loftus Versveld, Pretoria this Saturday at the Super Rugby Unlocked the latest game between the Blue Bulls and The Sharks; both with plenty of pride to play for in this South African rugby derby. Both Bulls and Sharks have a vast blend of youth and experience, as both teams are leading contenders to lift the South African Super Rugby Unlocked trophy this year. Previous Meetings: In many...

UFC 254: Khabib vs Gaethje – Main Card Preview

Main Card Preview UFC 254: UFC 254: Khabib vs. Gaethje will take place on October 24, 2020, at the Flash Forum on Yas Island, Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates. Khabib will look to defend his UFC title against Justin Gaethje in a fight Island classic for the ages. The co-main event features former middleweight champion Robert Whittaker taking on rising top contender Jared Cannonier. The 3 Fights To Look Forward To; Khabib Nurmagomedov vs Justin Gaethje Khabib Nurmagomedov...

Evander Holyfield – The Real Deal

Boxers have always had nicknames; sometimes chosen by themselves, sometimes bestowed upon them by the public or some other third party. The point of a nickname has either been to in some way highlight the intimidation factor of the boxer, or to help with the marketing of the fighter through the “catchiness” of the name. There’ve been some doozies, too. Jake “The Raging Bull” LaMotta, “Sugar” Ray Robinson, Seales, or Leonard, “Iron” Mike Tyson, or...

Can Barcelona Achieve Success This Season?

Will it be the fourth year that Barcelona faces a humiliating season or will they get their hands on the Champions League trophy for the sixth time? It has been a long time since 2015, that Barcelona last won the Champions League. What’s more disheartening are the heavy losses, the team has been suffering for the past few years. Obviously, last year's famous 8-2 thrashing from Bayern Munich highlighted the hollowness created in the team. And...

Fabinho Acrobatics Seals Liverpool Win

Reds opean European campaign with a win and solid defensive display

The Rejuvenation of Isaiah Thomas During the Pandemic

Isaiah Thomas has seen highs and lows like no other all-star in the NBA. From being an MVP candidate who finished 3rd in regular-season - MVP voting averaging of 29 points per game, to being traded the next year. And then being traded two more times from Washington to Denver and then on to the LA Clippers and then cut by the Clippers, it has been a real roller-coaster ride (not a good one)...

Lazio FC – The Rich History of Società Sportiva Lazio

Lazio Football Club is an Italian football club based in Rome, known mainly for their love for the beautiful game of soccer. They are annual participants in the Italian top league, Serie A, and usually pull their weight in challenging for titles and trophies. They have been Italian Scudetto winners twice in 1974 and 2000, and have lifted the prestigious Coppa Italia a whopping seven times, the Supercoppa Italiana three times and the European collections...

2020 World Series Preview/ Exciting Championship Reviews

A preview of the Dodger facing off against the Rays in the World Series. The Braves-Dodgers and Rays-Astros series wrap-up.
Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!