The “Bonecrusher”: James Odell Smith

One of my favourite sports memories has always been the unbridled joy on display from James “Bonecrusher” Smith after he knocked out then-champion Tim Witherspoon in the first round of their Dec. 12, 1986 WBA world title fight.

The date was already etched in my memory because it was also my now, ex-wife’s birthday; so fight night was a big day in the Auger-Villanueva household. Smith walked around the ring after the fight, hands raised, huge smile on his face, saying to himself over and over again “James Bonecrusher Smith, heavyweight champion of the world”, like he himself couldn’t believe it.

Witherspoon had entered that fight as a huge favourite but Smith never appeared daunted in any way by the task at hand, and set to work from the opening bell; nearly knocking “Terrible Tim” out with the very first punch he landed.

James “Bonecrusher” Smith, right, knocked out “Terrible” Tim Witherspoon in the first round of their fight at Madison Square Garden on Dec. 12, 1986, to win the WBA heavyweight championship. (Wilbur Funches / AP Photo)

The referee made a small mistake in stopping the fight automatically after the third knockdown in so much as the three-knockdown rule wasn’t actually in effect for the bout. But this was truly academic as the ending would not have changed. If anything, Witherspoon was spared more punishment and saved from what might have become a very dangerous situation had the fight been allowed to continue. In the end, all’s well that ends well seemed an apropos takeaway from the bout.

Smith would only be champion for about three months. On March 7, 1987, he would face the then-indomitable Mike Tyson in Las Vegas and although he lost a unanimous decision, Smith became one of the only men to last an entire fight with Tyson in his prime. He would get only one more shot at a title, retiring after the first round against the U.K.’s Joe Bugner when a shoulder popped out.

On reviewing Smith’s record though, I would put his list of opponents up against any heavyweight of any era, when it comes to the quality of the men he fought. Holmes (twice), Bruno, Witherspoon (twice), Tyson, Page, Moorer, Tubbs, Bugner, Marvis Frazier, Ribalta…the list goes on. What a resume! The man fought everybody!

I had the chance to sit down with Smith recently over a telephone interview and ask him a few questions about boxing yesterday and today, and what he’s been up to lately. I hadn’t seen any recent pictures of James but, in preparation for the bout, I looked up a few. Safe to say that this man has aged well. He’s huge, but in a good way.

He has the tell-tale shoulders of the power-athlete. It’s clear that even at 67-years-old, Smith isn’t someone you’d want to mess around with. Fortunately, his somewhat brooding presence is all but eliminated when he smiles. It’s a dazzling smile of a gentle giant.

David: James, how did you get involved in boxing in the first place?

James: Honestly man, I just wanted to be rich and famous. I was a good athlete – and strong, so boxing was a natural fit.

David: You certainly didn’t duck anybody. You fought US Olympian James Broad in your very first professional bout, then followed that up with the exceedingly competent Ricky Parkey. You fought Frank Bruno, Larry Holmes, Tony Tubbs, Jose Ribalta, Tim Witherspoon, Marvis Frazier, and Mike Weaver in a row! What’s even more remarkable is that you only had 14 fights under your belt when you started this streak.

That was literally the “who’s who” of the 80’s heavyweights. I don’t recall any other heavyweight having that many quality opponents in a row. Do you think you were brought long too fast? Why were you fighting for your life in every bout?

James: I didn’t have a lot of choice. I was a late starter. Had my first pro bout at 28-years-old. But I had talent, so I was beating a lot of these guys. It was just a natural progression. I learned quick. It actually helped me overall.

I think if Gerry Cooney had had some tougher fights before taking on Holmes, he might have beat him. But he had too many easy fights and wasn’t ready for what Larry brought to the table.

David: So what are your thoughts about the division today as opposed to your time, or even others?

James: I don’t really think it’s fair to compare different decades because the game changes over the years. Today’s guys are the best of the current crop. That’s all you can ask of them. Of course, there are some champions from yesterday who nobody can mess with.

David: Alright then, along that vein, give me your three greatest heavyweight champions of all-time?

James: That’s easy; Ali, Holmes, and Tyson.

David: How would James Smith have fared today?

James: Well, honestly, I believe that if I can land my right hand against any man’s head, I got a chance. I think I’d have done okay.

David: Who Is James Smith today? Is he still the “Bonecrusher”?

James: (stifles a little laugh) Actually, I’m an evangelist now. I’m teaming up with Earnie Shavers and Michael Spinks and we are doing a Boxing Legends Hall of Fame Mobile Museum coach tour.
David: Oh, what’s that?

James: Me, Earnie and Michael have teamed up to try to make a positive difference in the lives of our at-risk youth. There’s plenty of kids out there who need a little guidance. (I’m reminded at this point that Smith was a prison guard in the military, so he has a unique insight into troubled young men and women) What we’re doing is trying to raise enough money to buy a touring coach so we can travel the country, and even internationally, to help kids having problems.

For $100, a donor will receive recognition as being a “Founder”, will get a certificate, a colour photo of me fighting Mike Tyson, and their name on the wall of the Mobile Museum. Better yet, the donor will have the satisfaction of knowing they’ve done something really worthwhile.

David: That’s an amazing idea. Here’s my $100 right away. How can our readers help?

James: They can go to my website at and donate there.

David: I have a GoFundMe we can use as well. Folks, you can go to GoFundMe and search “Boxers In Need” to donate. It’s the one with the picture of a boxer on it – the man, not the dog, lol.

David: At the start of the interview, I asked you why you started boxing. You told me that you wanted to become rich and famous. Did you succeed?

James: Well, I’m certainly famous but I’d rather describe myself as comfortable than rich. I came along just when the money was getting really big for us. I just missed out on the huge paydays. I’ve got no complaints though. I’m a happy man.

With that, our time comes to an end. We say our goodbyes and I hang up the phone. My impression of James “Bonecrusher” Smith is overwhelmingly positive.

He is always trying to help. I think he might just be exactly what a true evangelist is all about; decent, kind, caring. James Smith is going to continue to be a positive force in the lives of many for years to come.

inbound4828739594705821625 scaled
David Auger-Villanueva
I was born in the Caribbean but grew up internationally. I've lived in Canada since 1974. I played just about every sport but was best at boxing. Fought in bareknuckles bouts, fight clubs, amateur, and pro. Married, father of four.
Notify of

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Sports News

2020 World Series Preview/ Exciting Championship Reviews

A preview of the Dodger facing off against the Rays in the World Series. The Braves-Dodgers and Rays-Astros series wrap-up.

Estrada Headlines World Title Triple Header on October 23

Matchroom USA will return to North America for the first time in over 8 weeks with an exciting World championship Triple Header topped by pound-for-pound star Juan Francisco Estrada. Estrada defends his WBC and Ring magazine belts against Carlos Cuadras in a rematch of their 'Mexican War' which took place in 2017. Roman Gonzalez faces off against Israel Gonzalez for Chocolatito's WBA (Super) Super-Flyweight title in the co-main event. The Nicaraguan won the title by...

Van Dijk injury gives Klopp the opportunity to reinvent Reds

Van Dijk faces lengthy time on the sidelines As the news finally broke on Van Dijk’s injury, one could almost sense a collective sigh of despair from the Liverpool fans. Their worst fears were confirmed as official word from the player arrived on social media. After undergoing further scans, the Dutch defender stated the following, “I’m now fully focused on my recovery and will do everything I can to be back as quickly as possible. Despite...

Maro Itoje: The Future Captain of England Rugby

The name Oghenemaro Itoje does not sound too familiar to many rugby enthusiasts, yet, when it's shortened to Maro Itoje, every England Rugby fan has words of praise for the latest English rugby superstar. The lock forward weighs in at a solid 115 KG, with his height being a whopping 1.95m. The presence of Itoje in The English forward’s has allowed it to find its backbone, where Itoje leads the pack. After a disappointing 2019...

Spurs Quick Start Ambushed by Lanzini’s Hammer

A fast start by Spurs Peep!....peep!, it was not even a minute before the referee blew the whistle for the second time. 45 seconds was all it took for Spurs to go ahead in this game, a start that even the Roadrunner would appreciate. The Lily Whites continued their rapid and mind-numbing start to the season as they rushed into a generous lead, with Kane at the heart of it. The English national...

Crawford Brook Agreed for November 14 on ESPN

On the Lomachenko-Lopez broadcast last night on ESPN, Top Rank announced another big fight just 4 weeks away. Terence Crawford will defend his WBO Welterweight title against Britain's Kell Brook on regular ESPN. This is another Top Rank mega-clash that could have landed on Pay-per-view but now lands on free-to-air television. Although this is a good fight on paper, the question here is how competitive will this fight really be? Brook has not boxed at...

Observation from the Milan Derby

AC Milan met Inter Milan for the first Milan derby for the 2010-21 season.  The match was an enthralling one, ending in a competitive 2-1 win for the ‘I Rossoneri.’ Zlatan Ibrahimovic scored early in the match, 13th and 16th minute before Romelu Lukaku put pulled one back for Inter Milan in the 28th minute. These were the only goals of the game. The win for AC Milan was their first since 2016 against their...

Talking Points – Merseyside Derby: Everton 2: 2 Liverpool

Excitement and anticipation were in the air, as the Merseyside derby kicked off on Saturday. Coming into this game, a lot had been written about the decade-old dominance by the red part of Merseyside in this derby. Carlo Ancelotti, the Everton coach had reposed his faith in the team stating in the pre-match conference, stating how his team looked focussed and was in good spirits. While Jurgen Klopp, who was still smarting from...

How NRL Finals Week Three Went Down

All eyes now turn to the Grand Finals of the NRL and the NRLW, following the latest weekend of games. Storm v Raiders The Melbourne Storm met the Canberra Raiders in Brisbane, playing for a Grand Final that meant everything to both of them. The night got off to an eventful start as a major outage caused disruptions at the ticket gate, leaving 20,000 fans locked out at kickoff. On the field, Storm hit the accelerator from...

A Happy Ending to a Tumultuous NBA Season

The NBA season came to a conclusion last weekend with the Los Angeles Lakers led by Finals Most Valuable Player, LeBron James, defeating the Miami Heat four games to two.  It was the Lakers 17th NBA championship (although my son won argue that we should only count the Los Angeles titles (12) and not the Minneapolis ones (5)  But that's another article for another day. While it was not the way I had hoped with...
Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x